Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) has lost its bid to collect €500,000 (RM2.3 million) in penalties from BYD after a Dutch court ruled that the Chinese carmaker had met its obligations during an evidence seizure linked to a dispute over the Land Rover Defender’s design.
The District Court of The Hague also lifted the seizure of BYD’s business records, finding that JLR had not established sufficient grounds to retain them.
The case centres on BYD’s Ti7 SUV, sold in China under its Fang Cheng Bao brand. JLR alleges that the vehicle infringes its registered design rights relating to the Defender.
In August, JLR obtained court permission to seize documents and digital records from BYD’s operations in Hoofddorp and Schiedam, including information concerning the Ti7’s development and planned European introduction.
However, the court found that the material was unnecessary to establish the alleged design infringement. JLR had sought the records partly to assess potential damages, but BYD had neither offered nor sold the Ti7 in the European Union.
The judge ruled that a possible future infringement could not justify retaining the evidence for a damages claim at that stage.
JLR’s separate attempt to impose penalties over alleged non-cooperation also failed.
The company had complained about delays in accessing laptops, network storage and cloud-based communications during the Aug 24 seizure.
But the court provisionally found that BYD had fulfilled its cooperation obligations. It also found that the bailiffs’ records did not adequately establish what further assistance was required or specify reasonable deadlines.
Under the ruling, JLR must instruct the court-appointed custodian or bailiff to destroy the seized material within 24 hours of formal service of the judgment. Confirmation must be provided to BYD within 24 hours after destruction.
Failure to comply carries a penalty of €50,000 (RM225,000) per hour, capped at €500,000.
JLR was also ordered to pay BYD €25,376.57 (RM114,157) in legal costs. A correction issued on Nov 12, following the Nov 11 judgment, confirmed JLR as the paying party.
The decision is a procedural setback for JLR rather than a ruling on whether the Ti7 copies the Defender. Separate infringement proceedings in The Hague and Rotterdam remain unresolved.
















